Bagel Plus

What Reddit says

A Bathurst and Sheppard bakery in Sheppard Plaza, praised for its rye bread, poppyseed danish and chocolate buffalo. Redditors recommend it for Ashkenazi baking and rank it near the top for bagels.

Paraphrased from the comments below.

What to order

• 7.9
  Bagels#7 for bagels in Toronto
  Worth trying
• Bread1 Redditor
• Pastries1 Redditor

In their words

Short excerpts, each linked to the full comment on Reddit.

• “Personally I am very fond of Bagel Plus at Sheppard Plaza”

• “I'm a fan of the rye at Bagel Plus up at bathurst and sheppard.”

• “Bagel Plus at Bathurst and Sheppard had a poppyseed danish that I adored.”

• “My favourite is from Bagel Plus at Bathurst and Sheppard”

• “Bagel plus is a close second.”

• “While you're there, grab a chocolate buffalo”

• “Bagel Plus at Bathurst and Sheppard are by far my favourite in the city”

• “Bagel Plus for Ashkenazi food”