Bagel Time

What Reddit says

Redditors strongly and repeatedly call it the best source of Montreal-style bagels in Toronto. Loyal fans praise the quality by a wide margin, and it's noted as one of few places doing this style.

Paraphrased from the comments below.

What to order

• 9.4
  Bagels#2 for bagels in Toronto
  Top pick

In their words

Short excerpts, each linked to the full comment on Reddit.

• “I genuinely think Bagel Time do the best Montreal bagels in the city.”

• “these bagels sustained me during my pregnancy in 2020.”

• “I am a Bagel Time loyalist. Best bagel in the city.”

• “Easily the best bagels in town, no contest. By a wide margin too.”

• “Best bagels in the city.”

• “Totally agree with this”

• “Bagel Time!”

• “That’s nice to hear. Love a bagel situation, and there aren’t too many, especially Montreal style”

• “What are their prices these days? It appears that they don't have a website.”

• “Where is this? What's the closest major intersection?”

• “Anyone know if the gluten free bagels are safe, and also good lol”

• “I went the other day for a bagel and cream cheese.”