Bartholomew Bakery

What Reddit says

Vaughan bakery praised for cinnamon rolls, sourdough and frozen chicken pot pie, with baking that isn't overly sweet. Frequently named as a top bakery pick. One person says it isn't worth a long drive and lineup.

Paraphrased from the comments below.

What to order

• 9.7
  Sandwiches#1 for sandwiches in Toronto
  Top pick
• 9.3
  Bread#2 for bread in Toronto
  Top pick
• 7.8
  Croissants17 Redditors
  Worth trying
• 7.7
  Pastries19 Redditors
  Worth trying
• Cookies5 Redditors
• Pizza2 Redditors
• Cake1 Redditor
• Cinnamon & Cardamom Buns1 Redditor

In their words

Short excerpts, each linked to the full comment on Reddit.

• “Their sourdough and mortadella sandwich is to die for as well”

• “Everything tasted fresh, high-quality, and honestly just addictive. Definitely worth it.”

• “Everything I’ve tasted from them has been delicious and not overly sweet. The cinnamon roll is amazing.”

• “Went to Bartholomew - everything was good!”

• “The mortadella sandwich was unreal.”

• “Worth the trip to Vaughan for the cookies from Bartholomew Bakery if underbaked is what you're after!”

• “Bakery: Bartholomew Bakery”

• “One of the best bakeries in GTA.”

• “They are super well-made so airy on the inside and very crunchy, but sometimes they taste like the dough was frozen for a long time”

• “Love them but don’t love the long lines. Their almond croissant is ridiculous”

• “Love this bakery! It’s my husband’s and my fave!”

• “Honestly their croissants aren’t that good in my opinion. That make some other pastries that are fantastic though.”