Centre Street Deli

What Reddit says

Jewish-style deli with a downtown Bay Street location and a Thornhill one, known for matzo ball soup and hot sandwiches. Fans love it, but critics complain about high prices, small portions and a lukewarm sandwich.

Paraphrased from the comments below.

What to order

• 7.6
  Smoked Meat & Pastrami#4 for smoked meat & pastrami in Toronto
  Top pick
• 3.9
  Sandwiches17 Redditors
  Worth trying
• Fries3 Redditors
• Bread1 Redditor
• Brunch1 Redditor
• Salads & Bowls1 Redditor

In their words

Short excerpts, each linked to the full comment on Reddit.

• “their prices were insulting for what it was”

• “I went in there once, spent 30+ to still be hungry. This place was idiotic.”

• “The sandwich (meant to be served hot) was barely room temp.”

• “$17 or so for a sandwich the size of a small child’s fist.”

• “Centre St Deli on Bay”

• “best smoked meat sandwich you’ll get without driving all the way to Montreal. Their fries are really good, too.”

• “the chicken soup came out boiling hot in a paper cup with a shitty little plastic spoon, even for dine-in.”

• “There’s hardly any deli’s downtown and I liked their stuff.”

• “Centre Street Deli is my fav.”

• “Original centre street in thornhill is amazing. The one on Bay isn't nearly as good”

• “I bought come kreplach and they were still frozen in the middle”

• “they took good food and poorly prepared it, and with none of the deli experience.”