Cookeys

What Reddit says

A cookie shop near Yonge and St. Clair known for thick, chunky cookies, with chocolate chip singled out. Opinions on price are split, with some finding the roughly $6.50 cookies overpriced and others loving them.

Paraphrased from the comments below.

What to order

• 6.6
  Cookies#22 for cookies in Toronto
  Worth trying

In their words

Short excerpts, each linked to the full comment on Reddit.

• “The chocolate chip cookie is probably their best in my experience, though I like the white chocolate chip as well”

• “I’ve tried 3 cookies and they were definitely good, but, I did feel a bit ill after eating them each time”

• “the cookies are very good: thick and chunky”

• “Solid in general! You can definitely finish it in one go but can responsibly halve / or quarter it.”

• “I liked the cookies and they were big but they are expensive, $6.50 each. I'd go back”

• “Cookies taste good, but are they worth $6.50? Not so sure”

• “Tried it for the first time and to be honest, it was ok (not mind blowing)”

• “I have tried alot of cookies in Toronto and I love these the most!”

• “But I think these cookies might be approximately the same circumference, but have more depth and chunkiness within.”

• “I found them overpriced and underwhelming.”

• “I liked the cookies though, and I would go again.”

• “they are so chunky that they're not comparable to many”