Craig's Cookies

What Reddit says

A Toronto cookie shop with several locations. Most Redditors are lukewarm, calling the cookies too sweet and unremarkable, and one mentions unfriendly service around tipping. A few people do enjoy them.

Paraphrased from the comments below.

What to order

• 1.8
  Cookies58 Redditors
  Worth trying
• Banana Pudding5 Redditors

In their words

Short excerpts, each linked to the full comment on Reddit.

• “Had this last night and I give it my ringing approval.”

• “It's better than their cookies lol, I hope they make it a permanent menu item”

• “I hope it’s not a Craig’s cookie ripoff”

• “No Craig's cookies. Meh cookies, entitled staff that scowl if you don't tip.”

• “i find their cookies to be so disgustingly salty and no one ever agrees with me”

• “Honestly I find Craig’s are just short of a heart attack when it comes to salt”

• “Craig’s cookies are way too sweet for me”

• “But the salt is the balance for me. It’s just what I’m looking for in a cookie.”

• “That is Craig’s to a T”

• “Just had these for the first time last weekend and I'm hooked! I love cookies and Craig knows what he's doing.”

• “I didnt like it. Like everything at Craig's cookies, it was too salty.”

• “While Craig's Cookies isn't really MY thing, they're a very popular Toronto-originating chain and should travel fairly well.”