Skip to content
UpvoteEats, Toronto
7.4out of 10

Donatelli's Pizzeria

Pizza in Islington, Toronto

#1,513 in Toronto. 6 Redditors across 13 mentions, Nov 2023 to Aug 2026.

Get directions (opens Google Maps)5230 Dundas Street West

Closed or moved? Let us know

What Reddit says

Known for pizza by the slice in Etobicoke's west end. The pesto pepperoni square gets a specific shout-out, and one Redditor calls it the best slice around.

Paraphrased from the comments below.

What to order

In their words

Short excerpts, each linked to the full comment on Reddit.

More in Islington

  1. 8.4

    Chodang Soontofu

    Korean in Islington

    11 Redditors

  2. 7.9

    Bake Sale Toronto

    Bakery, Dessert in Islington

    9 Redditors

  3. 7.8

    Amma's Kitchen

    Indian in Islington

    8 Redditors

  4. 7.8

    Shawarma Club

    Middle Eastern in Islington

    7 Redditors