The Fourth Man in the Fire Pizzeria

What to order

• 9.6
  Cinnamon & Cardamom Buns#2 for cinnamon & cardamom buns in Toronto
  Top pick
• 9.1
  Donuts#3 for donuts in Toronto
  Top pick
• 8.6
  Sandwiches15 Redditors
  Worth trying
• 8.6
  Detroit & Square Pizza#3 for Detroit & square pizza in Toronto
  Top pick
• 7.3
  Pizza62 Redditors
  Worth trying
• 7.0
  Pizza by the Slice23 Redditors
  Worth trying
• Apple Fritters4 Redditors
• Italian Sandwiches (veal4 Redditors

In their words

Short excerpts, each linked to the full comment on Reddit.

• “Way too much honey on it for my taste. Way too sweet, our lowest rated pizza is the day.”

• “Honestly one of my favourite slices in the city. Super underrated. Their apple fritter is bomb as well!”

• “apple fritter from fourth man in the fire (bonus if you get the pizza slice combo with a donut and pop for $11) on dundas”

• “Pizza was okay, but their donuts are so good! Especially their plain chocolate donut”

• “● Fourth Man in the Fire ● North of Brooklyn ● Fresca”

• “This is my top za in the city along with fourth man.”

• “Fourth man is good, but not on the level of Badiali or Brooklyn. Their subs are legit though.”

• “The Brooklyn squares pizza from Fourth Man in the Fire is the most delicious insane deep dish pizza I’ve had in my life”

• “I also love the Real American Hero from Fourth Man in the Fire.”

• “panzo from fourth man in the fire, fried in the oil they use to fry their donuts”

• “Nice Slice Mac’s Grams Fresca Fourth Man in the Fire One Night Only Gracie’s”

• “Consider somewhere like Fourth Man in the Fire, maybe? Get a couple of pizzas and a salad or two to share.”