Skip to content
UpvoteEats, Toronto
6.3out of 10

Gatsby (Windsor Arms Hotel)

Cafés, French in Yorkville, Toronto

Also in Bay-Cloverhill

#3,218 in Toronto. 5 Redditors across 8 mentions, Apr 2024 to Jan 2026.

Closed or moved? Let us know

What Reddit says

Windsor Arms Hotel restaurant, mostly discussed for its traditional afternoon tea with generous sandwiches and desserts. The room is called stunning, though a former employee described poor cleanliness in the kitchen.

Paraphrased from the comments below.

What to order

In their words

Short excerpts, each linked to the full comment on Reddit.

More in Yorkville

  1. 8.8

    Dessert Lady Cafe & Bakery

    Bakery, Dessert, Cafés in Yorkville

    70 Redditors

  2. 8.7

    Nani's Gelato

    Dessert in Church and Wellesley

    91 Redditors

  3. 8.5

    79 Redditors

  4. 8.4

    Da.si.mar Shawarma

    Middle Eastern, Mediterranean in Church and Wellesley

    14 Redditors