Gryfe's

What Reddit says

A long-standing Toronto bagel bakery. Fans call the double poppyseed the best flavour and praise the midnight cookie. Detractors find the bagels small, bland and bun-like, so opinions are split.

Paraphrased from the comments below.

What to order

• 7.5
  Bagels#11 for bagels in Toronto
  Worth trying
• Cookies1 Redditor

In their words

Short excerpts, each linked to the full comment on Reddit.

• “Gryfe’s are the only bagel in Toronto worth doing this for and the double poppyseed is the best flavour.”

• “Was skeptical because I'm picky about bagels but these were really good!”

• “Gryfe’s are good but a totally different style.”

• “Gryfe's tastes like a loaf of bread shaped like a bagel. Really don't understand the hype.”

• “Those are THE softest and most amazing bagels besides st. Urbain for me, and their pizza bagels are to die for!”

• “I also really like Gryfe's on Bathurst, North of Lawrence for bagels to go.”

• “To me, Gryfe’s is the standard for what a Toronto bagel is.”

• “Gryfes”

• “I won't take this Gryfes slander”

• “Gryfe's is a staple :) Glad you enjoyed!”

• “the bag of gryfe’s bagels in a paper bag in the back seat of the car emanating the best smell”

• “I like them better than MTL bagels”