Makers

What Reddit says

Local pizza group with several locations that once had a strong following. Recent comments are mostly negative, citing high prices for whole pies, declining quality and menu items being dropped. Slices are seen as the better value.

Paraphrased from the comments below.

What to order

• 5.8
  Pizza by the Slice5 Redditors
  Worth trying
• 5.0
  Pizza21 Redditors
  Worth trying
• Bread1 Redditor
• Cookies1 Redditor
• Doner & Gyros1 Redditor

In their words

Short excerpts, each linked to the full comment on Reddit.

• “They are wayyyy too pricey for a whole pie. Only time I get them now is for their slices”

• “I ordered my first Maker recently for the first time in at least a couple years and thought it was garbage.”

• “That was a great pizza, and like most of their best pizzas they took it off the menu.”

• “I used to love getting it (Thornhill and the Lawrence store) but lately? Just not that exciting.”

• “Makers, Sugo, Badiali, slowhand, definitely up there.”

• “Makers pizza lets you get any of their pizzas “tavern style”, which sounds like what you’re looking for.”

• “I remember when they first opened and I tried their Big Mac pizza, it was so freaking good.”

• “I also like makers, in part because their garlic sauce is a step above”

• “The prices are outrageous for the size. I live near the one on bayview and it’s always empty in there”

• “They've really slipped in the last while.”

• “at best they’re hit or miss. Incredibly overpriced. And, overall not worth your money.”

• “Makers is my splurge, i do love getting a Dr Pep with Hot wheel/olive/peppers/poppy crust”