Sea Witch Fish and Chips

What Reddit says

Best known for beef tallow fries, which many Redditors call among the best in the city. The tallow poutine also gets praise, and some say the fries beat the fish.

Paraphrased from the comments below.

What to order

• 8.3
  Poutine#3 for poutine in Toronto
  Top pick
• 5.8
  Fish and Chips75 Redditors
  Worth trying
• 5.8
  Fries19 Redditors
  Worth trying
• Fish Sandwiches3 Redditors
• Onion Rings2 Redditors
• Sandwiches2 Redditors
• Tacos1 Redditor

In their words

Short excerpts, each linked to the full comment on Reddit.

• “The fish & Chips at Sea With was worth the hype and recommendation!”

• “The fish sandwich from Sea Witch is pretty close to my favourite meal in this entire city.”

• “Sea Witch on St.Clair West. The seasonal perch is excellent.”

• “Sea Witch on St. Clair W!”

• “Sea Witch on St Clair Ave W. is my go to, casual eat in or takeout. Not cheap but excellent quality.”

• “They're the best.”

• “Nothing else even comes close in this town for Fish n Chips.”

• “The batter was undercooked and really thick, leaving just a finger-sized piece of fish inside.”

• “Sea Witch on St Clair West does a great one with pickled onions! So good.”

• “Their pickerel sandwich is one of the best fish sandwiches in Toronto.”

• “Sea Witch Fish and Chips”

• “JABS Burgers, Sea Witch, Itacate, Emma’s Country Kitchen, Lox and Schmear, Primrose Bagels, Porzia’s”