Bagels on Fire

What Reddit says

Bagels on Fire is known for salty, Montreal-style bagels and is often ranked alongside Primrose and Nu Bagel. Opinions are mostly positive, though one Redditor finds them dry and too sweet.

Paraphrased from the comments below.

What to order

• 8.5
  Bagels#4 for bagels in Toronto
  Top pick

In their words

Short excerpts, each linked to the full comment on Reddit.

• “Primrose and Bagels on fire are amazing”

• “Bagels on Fire have nice salty Montreal bagels”

• “I don’t like Bagels on Fire, I find them dry and too sweet.”

• “Bagels on fire are pretty good!”

• “Primrose and Bagels on Fire destroy Gryfe's!”

• “Coconut bagels from Bagels on Fire.”

• “I will take Bagels on Fire anytime.”

• “Bagels on Fire on Queen East has some of the best bagels in the city.”

• “I'd say Nu Bagel, followed by Bagels on Fire.”

• “I always make sure to have Bagels on Fire bagels in my freezer, they are excellent!”

• “BOF is possibly second best in city behind Primrose.”

• “Bagels on fire in the beach”