Benny's Barbecue

What Reddit says

Texas-style barbecue near Yonge and Eglinton, with brisket often named among the best in the city. Complaints include short hours and running out of food early. One report says it closed indefinitely after a flood.

Paraphrased from the comments below.

What to order

• 8.5
  Barbecue#3 for barbecue in Toronto
  Top pick
• Mac and Cheese3 Redditors
• Cornbread1 Redditor

In their words

Short excerpts, each linked to the full comment on Reddit.

• “Brisket was super moist. Ribs were fall off the bone. Sausage was mediocre. Brisket beans were surprisingly delicious.”

• “Benny's Smoking Section Barbecue Golden Horseshoe Barbecue”

• “came away from it thinking some dishes were just okay while some were phenomenal”

• “Bennys is nice. Yonge and Eg”

• “I'd recommend you do. I think their brisket might just edge out Cherry St's.”

• “Very tasty! Similar tier to Cherry Street BBQ”

• “I showed up last minute and the cook gave me some for free... and OMG”

• “Honestly bennys is classic junk bbq. It’s ok every now and then.”

• “Benny’s bbq and golden horseshoe are top tier as well”

• “Benny’s is solid value.”

• “I really thought Benny’s was superior in nearly every meat.”

• “Benny's BBQ. The brisket is just too good.”