Buster's Sea Cove

What Reddit says

Seafood counter at St. Lawrence Market known for its lobster roll. Redditors say the food is fresh and tasty but the roll is small for about $23, with several calling it a tourist trap. Po boys are seen as better value.

Paraphrased from the comments below.

What to order

• 7.7
  Sandwiches9 Redditors
  Worth trying
• 7.2
  Fish and Chips#22 for fish and chips in Toronto
  Worth trying
• 5.3
  Fries6 Redditors
  Worth trying
• 4.6
  Seafood17 Redditors
  Worth trying
• 1.0
  Lobster Rolls#5 for lobster rolls in Toronto
  Top pick
• Fish Sandwiches5 Redditors
• Calamari & Octopus3 Redditors
• Falafel1 Redditor

In their words

Short excerpts, each linked to the full comment on Reddit.

• “It was good, but not “wow.” Still, $23 plus tax for a roll the length of my finger feels like a rip-off.”

• “for the price, the roll is tasty and a good portion.”

• “it was never fresh lobster or the greatest value, it didn't used to look this lazily prepared or as bad as what OP posted.”

• “It really is terrible (Buster’s). It’s real lobster but it is a fine shredded paste and you still don’t get much of it.”

• “this was the most digusting shit ive eaten. so fcking greasy too.”

• “The lobster roll was bland, underwhelming, very wet. wouldn't do that again.”

• “It was fresh and nicely seasoned however the portion can be bigger since they're charging $23.”

• “This was a rip off. I tried it this summer and it tasted like a glorified tuna sandwich.”

• “This has become my favorite spot for a Friday splurge lunch”

• “my post indicates the lobster roll was wet and bland and disappointing and not worth the price”

• “My Cape Breton ass rejected it like an organ transplant”

• “They buy the meat in huge plastic bags of frozen mashed lobster meat and defrost until it’s wet.”