4 Redditors across 7 mentions, Aug 2025 to Nov 2025. Not enough people have weighed in to score it yet.
What Reddit says
A home-based baker known for butter tarts, with no storefront. Some Redditors love them and have bought them for years, while others find them average with ordinary ingredients. Opinions are mixed.
Paraphrased from the comments below.
What to order
- 6.2Butter Tarts#17 for butter tarts in TorontoWorth trying
In their words
Short excerpts, each linked to the full comment on Reddit.
“Carla's Cookie Box makes excellent butter tarts however she does not have a shop.”
Liked itr/FoodToronto, Nov 2025Read on Reddit (opens in a new tab) “I wasn't impressed with Carla's. Very average and not the best ingredients”
Not a fanr/FoodToronto, Nov 2025Read on Reddit (opens in a new tab) “Yrs I have had butter tarts from Carla's. I love them!”
Loved itr/FoodToronto, Nov 2025Read on Reddit (opens in a new tab) “Also dece: Carla's Cookie Box; Sweetie Pie; Gerard St. Bakery”
Liked itr/FoodToronto, Aug 2025Read on Reddit (opens in a new tab) “They are ok in my opinion.”
Mixedr/FoodToronto, Nov 2025Read on Reddit (opens in a new tab) “Have you ever tried butter tarts from Carla's Cookie Box?”
Mentionedr/FoodToronto, Nov 2025Read on Reddit (opens in a new tab) “I haven't tried Carla's Cookie box, is it good?”
Mentionedr/FoodToronto, Nov 2025Read on Reddit (opens in a new tab)
More in Vaughan
- 9.3
46 Redditors
- 9.1
21 Redditors
- 8.5
31 Redditors
- 8.5
35 Redditors