The best butter tarts in Toronto
Ranked by Reddit
14 places ranked for butter tarts, from what 324 Redditors said about it. Scores are for the butter tarts specifically, not the restaurant overall.
Last updated . How the ranking works
- 9.8#1
1. 13th Street WineryTop pick
9 Redditors on the butter tarts
“I’d head to 13th street winery for what I think are the best butter tarts out there.”
Loved itr/FoodToronto, Feb 2026Read on Reddit (opens in a new tab) - 9.6#2
2. Ba NoiTop pick
158 Redditors on the butter tarts
“It absolutely lives up the hype and cult following IMO.”
Loved itr/FoodToronto, Mar 2025Read on Reddit (opens in a new tab) - 9.6#3
3. MattachioniTop pick
10 Redditors on the butter tarts
“I went on a weekday at noon and everything was quiet and cozy, and I loved their butter tarts.”
Liked itr/FoodToronto, Nov 2025Read on Reddit (opens in a new tab) - 9.5#4
4. BrodflourTop pick
10 Redditors on the butter tarts
“Brodflour and Banoi are my fav”
Loved itr/FoodToronto, Jul 2026Read on Reddit (opens in a new tab) - 9.4#5
5. Sweetie PieTop pick
10 Redditors on the butter tarts
“We recommend Sweetie Pie, in the Distillery. Best butter tarts.”
Loved itr/FoodToronto, Jul 2026Read on Reddit (opens in a new tab)
- 9.3#6
6. Gerrard Street BakeryWorth trying
13 Redditors on the butter tarts
“Gerrard Street bakery has a ton of yummy baked goods - notably known for their butter tarts”
Liked itr/FoodToronto, Sep 2024Read on Reddit (opens in a new tab) - 8.9#7
7. Larry's PlaceWorth trying
9 Redditors on the butter tarts
“Best coffee, best coffee shops and one of the best butter tarts in the game”
Loved itr/FoodToronto, Aug 2025Read on Reddit (opens in a new tab) - 8.8#8
8. Circles & Squares BakeryWorth trying
58 Redditors on the butter tarts
“it’s a really well balanced butter tart”
Liked itr/FoodToronto, Nov 2025Read on Reddit (opens in a new tab) - 8.5#9
9. TartistryWorth trying
5 Redditors on the butter tarts
“I love their tarts and when I get them I’ve never had complaints from people who can eat gluten.”
Liked itr/FoodToronto, Nov 2025Read on Reddit (opens in a new tab) - 8.5#10
10. The Pie CommissionWorth trying
14 Redditors on the butter tarts
“Best in Show and 1st Place Professional Traditional Winner: The Pie Commission's Pecan Butter Tart”
Loved itr/FoodToronto, Jun 2024Read on Reddit (opens in a new tab) - 8.5#11
11. The Maids' CottageWorth trying
9 Redditors on the butter tarts
“IMO, the GOAT-tier Ontario butter tart is from The Maid's Cottage in Newmarket.”
Loved itr/FoodToronto, Nov 2025Read on Reddit (opens in a new tab) - 8.1#12
12. Bad AttitudeWorth trying
3 Redditors on the butter tarts
“They're so good. Their croissants are "how is this vegan!?" and so are their butter tarts.”
Liked itr/FoodToronto, Mar 2026Read on Reddit (opens in a new tab) - 7.9#13
13. Gerrard St. BakeryWorth trying
12 Redditors on the butter tarts
“Prob my fav butter tart along w Gerrard St Bakery.”
Loved itr/FoodToronto, Aug 2026Read on Reddit (opens in a new tab) - 7.5#14
14. Charmaine SweetsWorth trying
4 Redditors on the butter tarts
“[Charmaine Sweets](https://www.charmainesweetsstudio.com/menu)”
Loved itr/FoodToronto, Aug 2025Read on Reddit (opens in a new tab)