Mattachioni

What Reddit says

Dupont Neapolitan-style pizzeria and bakery. Redditors praise the pizza crust, bread, sandwiches and butter tarts, and consistently recommend it for a sit-down meal.

Paraphrased from the comments below.

What to order

• 9.6
  Butter Tarts#3 for butter tarts in Toronto
  Top pick
• 9.0
  Italian Sandwiches (veal#4 for Italian sandwiches (veal in Toronto
  Top pick
• 8.9
  Bread#6 for bread in Toronto
  Worth trying
• 8.8
  Neapolitan Pizza#1 for Neapolitan pizza in Toronto
  Top pick
• 8.7
  Pizza#19 for pizza in Toronto
  Worth trying
• 8.2
  Sandwiches15 Redditors
  Worth trying
• Salads & Bowls4 Redditors
• Pasta3 Redditors

In their words

Short excerpts, each linked to the full comment on Reddit.

• “The pizza is my fave Neaoplitan pie in the city, and their sandwiches are incredible.”

• “I absolutely love Mattachioni’s sourdough, pizzas, and vibe in general”

• “The porchetta sandwich at Mattachioni or a dinner at Dottys are both great”

• “I think their pizza is greatly underrated. My favourite Neapolitan style in the city.”

• “you can pick up a loaf of the best sourdough in the city”

• “I also second Mattachioni.”

• “I went on a weekday at noon and everything was quiet and cozy, and I loved their butter tarts.”

• “house-made sourdough that’s incredible and a full dinner menu”

• “I get sandwiches from Mattachioni, Masa Deli, Lambo's, Tutto Panini, Ariete e Toro, and Alfie's.”

• “Mattachioni is delicious and cozy but expect slower service.”

• “But also stay for dinner as the food is awesome!”

• “Mattachioni has an eggplant sandwich that often pulls me away from their meat ones.”