Skip to content
UpvoteEats, Toronto

Best Italian restaurants in Toronto

Ranked by Reddit

Last updated . How the ranking works

  1. 9.3#1

    1. Futura Granita + GelatoTemporarily closed

    Dessert, Italian in Corso Italia

    76 Redditors

  2. 9.1#2

    21 Redditors

  3. 9.0#3

    3. Frank's Pizza House

    Pizza, Italian in Corso Italia

    40 Redditors

  4. 9.0#4

    4. Palma Pasta

    Italian in Mississauga

    20 Redditors

  5. 9.0#5

    5. Pizza e Pazzi

    Pizza, Italian in Corso Italia

    30 Redditors

  6. 8.9#6

    6. Abruzzo Pizza

    Pizza, Italian in Richmond Hill

    22 Redditors

  7. 8.8#7

    7. Alimentari Italian Grocery

    Italian, Bakery in Roncesvalles

    35 Redditors

  8. 8.7#8

    34 Redditors

  9. 8.5#9

    9. Mattachioni

    Pizza, Italian, Sandwiches in Junction-Wallace Emerson

    123 Redditors

  10. 8.5#10

    10. North Pole Bakery

    Bakery, Italian, Dessert in Danforth

    56 Redditors

  11. 8.4#11

    11. Viaggio

    Italian, Pizza in Little Portugal

    108 Redditors

  12. 8.4#12

    55 Redditors

  13. 8.4#13

    13. Butcher Chef

    Steakhouse, Italian in Harbourfront

    82 Redditors

  14. 8.4#14

    14. Bar Eugenie

    Italian, Bar in University

    42 Redditors

  15. 8.4#15

    15. Grape Witches

    Bar, Italian in Ossington

    38 Redditors

  16. 8.4#16

    144 Redditors

  17. 8.3#17

    17. Spaghetti Western

    Italian, Sandwiches in East End-Danforth

    19 Redditors

  18. 8.3#18

    18. FK

    Italian, Bar in Wychwood

    106 Redditors

  19. 8.3#19

    19. Bellona

    Italian, Vegan in Little Italy

    108 Redditors

  20. 8.2#20

    46 Redditors

  21. 8.2#21

    179 Redditors

  22. 8.1#22

    22. Tutti Matti

    Italian in Entertainment District

    54 Redditors

  23. 8.1#23

    19 Redditors

  24. 8.1#24

    24. Forno Cultura

    Bakery, Sandwiches, Italian in King West

    158 Redditors

  25. 8.1#25

    25. Crudo Pizza & Panuozzo

    Sandwiches, Italian, Pizza in Humber Heights-Westmount

    88 Redditors

  26. 8.1#26

    26. Capra's Kitchen

    Italian in Mississauga

    19 Redditors

  27. 8.1#27

    27. F'Amelia

    Italian in Cabbagetown

    21 Redditors

  28. 8.0#28

    28. Tatsuro's

    Japanese, Italian, Breakfast & Brunch in Leslieville

    38 Redditors

  29. 8.0#29

    29. Morellina's

    Italian in Koreatown

    28 Redditors

  30. 8.0#30

    30. Pizzeria Defina

    Pizza, Italian in Roncesvalles

    70 Redditors

  31. 8.0#31

    31. Amico Bakery

    Bakery, Italian in Yorkdale-Glen Park

    27 Redditors

  32. 8.0#32

    32. Notte Ristorante

    Italian in St. Lawrence Market

    8 Redditors

  33. 8.0#33

    33. JZ's Pizza

    Pizza, Italian in Entertainment District

    10 Redditors

  34. 7.9#34

    22 Redditors

  35. 7.9#35

    105 Redditors

  36. 7.9#36

    36. Bar Ardo

    Italian, Bar in St. Lawrence Market

    25 Redditors

  37. 7.9#37

    37. Restaurant Stop

    Mediterranean, Italian in Roncesvalles

    14 Redditors

  38. 7.9#38

    38. 7 Numbers

    Italian in Riverdale

    52 Redditors

  39. 7.9#39

    39. Armonia Pasta Bar

    Italian in Parkdale

    8 Redditors

  40. 7.9#40

    40. Messina Bakery

    Bakery, Italian, Sandwiches in Rockcliffe-Smythe

    17 Redditors

  41. 7.9#41

    41. Ardo

    Italian, Seafood in St. Lawrence Market

    65 Redditors

  42. 7.9#42

    42. Pasta Forever

    Italian, Sandwiches in Dundas West

    26 Redditors

  43. 7.9#43

    43. Terrazza

    Italian in Palmerston-Little Italy

    15 Redditors

  44. 7.9#44

    55 Redditors

  45. 7.8#45

    45. Bar Volo

    Bar, Italian in Bay-Cloverhill

    137 Redditors

  46. 7.8#46

    46. Gatto Wood Oven Pizza

    Pizza, Italian in Bloor West Village

    5 Redditors

  47. 7.8#47

    47. Tiny Market Co.Temporarily closed

    Italian in Annex

    61 Redditors

  48. 7.8#48

    48. Sambucas on Church

    Italian, American in Church and Wellesley

    9 Redditors

  49. 7.8#49

    49. Dreyfus

    French, Italian in University

    207 Redditors

  50. 7.8#50

    22 Redditors

More ranked Italian restaurants

  1. Tutto Panino7.8
  2. Venga Cucina7.7
  3. Bar Vendetta7.7
  4. Cafe Oro di Napoli7.7
  5. Trattoria Nervosa7.7
  6. Fangio Trattoria7.7
  7. Pizzeria Fornace7.7
  8. Parma Pizza7.7
  9. Caffino7.7
  10. Dulcinella7.7
  11. Lamanna's Bakery7.6
  12. La Bettola Di Terroni7.6
  13. Ragu Scratch Pasta7.6
  14. Gio Rana's Really Really Nice7.6
  15. Fuoco Mio7.6
  16. Oro Cafe and Eatery7.6
  17. Pizzeria Via Mercanti7.6
  18. Ladybug Wine Bar7.6
  19. Henry's Restaurant & Wine Bar7.6
  20. Speducci Mercatto7.6
  21. Contrada7.6
  22. Terra Restaurants7.6
  23. Classico Louie's Pizzeria7.6
  24. Za Cafe Pizzeria + Bar7.5
  25. Cantina Mercatto7.5
  26. Napoli Centrale7.5
  27. Queen Margherita Pizza7.5
  28. Trattoria Mercatto7.5
  29. Montmartre Bakery7.5
  30. Ferro7.5
  31. Ciao Roma7.5
  32. David Rocco Bar Aperitivo7.5
  33. La Casetta7.5
  34. Locale7.5
  35. Trattoria Fieramosca7.5
  36. Blue River House7.5
  37. Rocco's Plum Tomato7.5
  38. La Focaccia7.4
  39. 7 Numbers7.4
  40. Pasta Privato7.4
  41. Carisma7.4
  42. Bar Allegro7.4
  43. Annette Food Market7.4
  44. Radici Project7.4
  45. San Antonio Seafood Market & Oyster Bar7.4
  46. Donatello7.4
  47. Terroni Sud Forno Produzione e Spaccio (Spaccio East)7.4
  48. Remezzo7.3
  49. Bar Prima7.3
  50. No Vacancy7.3
  51. Gusto 1017.3
  52. San Antonio Foods7.3
  53. Bar Mercurio7.3
  54. Osteria Giulia7.3
  55. Biagio Ristorante7.3
  56. Domaine Mamo7.3
  57. St. Philips7.3
  58. Coco Espresso Bar7.3
  59. CKB7.3
  60. Trattoria Taverniti7.3
  61. Tre Mari Bakery7.2
  62. Gusto 5017.2
  63. Giulietta7.2
  64. Grande Cheese7.2
  65. Marcello's Pizzeria7.2
  66. East End Vine7.2
  67. Vicentina Meats7.2
  68. Annabelle Pasta Bar7.2
  69. The Hamptons7.2
  70. TreRose Bakery Bistro and Deli7.2
  71. Perla Oyster Bar & Grill7.2
  72. Gemma Gelateria7.2
  73. Il Ponte7.2
  74. Tutto Pronto7.2
  75. Lady York Foods7.2
  76. Dino's Wood Burning Pizza7.2
  77. Tuscan Wolf Pizzeria7.2
  78. La Salumeria Delicatessen7.1
  79. Zitto Zitto Taverna7.1
  80. Cataldi Fresh Market7.1
  81. Bottega Volo7.1
  82. General Assembly Pizza7.1
  83. Monte Bianco7.1
  84. Sud Forno7.1
  85. Papa Mio's7.1
  86. Forno Cultura (MOCA)7.1
  87. San Remo Bakery7.1
  88. Porta Via7.1
  89. Papa Giuseppe's7.1
  90. Lardo7.1
  91. Stelvio7.1
  92. Sorento Italian Kitchen7.0
  93. Grappa7.0
  94. Desserts Plus Ristorante & Woodburning Pizza7.0
  95. Cafe Parmesan7.0
  96. Constantine7.0
  97. Le Dolci7.0
  98. Kara Mia7.0
  99. Il Postino Ristorante7.0
  100. Archeo Trattoria7.0
  101. De Sotos7.0
  102. Bologna Pastificio6.9
  103. Wynona6.9
  104. La Bruschetta6.9
  105. Vibo6.9
  106. Sunday Pasta Lab6.9
  107. Francobollo6.9
  108. Gemma Gelateria6.9
  109. Cal's Zone6.9
  110. California Sandwiches6.9
  111. Francesca Bakery6.9
  112. Gia6.8
  113. Avant Goût6.8
  114. Elm Street Italian Deli6.8
  115. Levetto6.8
  116. Casa di Giorgio6.8
  117. Atelier Pasta6.8
  118. Anima Romana Bakery6.8
  119. The Tiramisu Guy6.8
  120. Y Not Italian!6.8
  121. Bar Filo6.8
  122. Ferraro6.8
  123. Cano6.8
  124. Capocaccia6.8
  125. Enoteca Sociale6.8
  126. Regina Trattoria & Pizzeria6.7
  127. Nodo6.7
  128. Paese6.7
  129. Fratelli Village Pizzeria6.7
  130. Uno Mustachio6.7
  131. Raffaella6.7
  132. TAVERNA Mercatto6.7
  133. Florin Trattoria6.7
  134. Bellissimo's6.7
  135. Milano's Pizza6.7
  136. Famoso Pizzeria + Bar6.6
  137. Pala 1486.6
  138. Campo6.6
  139. St. Lawrence Pizza & Pasta6.6
  140. Queen's Pasta Café6.6
  141. Il Paesano Pizzeria and Restaurant6.6
  142. Carolina6.6
  143. Molisana Bakery6.6
  144. Il Fornello6.6
  145. Parcheggio6.6
  146. Dante's Pizzeria6.5
  147. Buca King Street West6.5
  148. Bridgette Bar6.5
  149. Rasta Pasta6.5
  150. Bar Poet6.5
  151. Eden Trattoria6.5
  152. Sotto Voce Wine & Pasta Bar6.5
  153. Nino D'Aversa Bakery6.5
  154. Vilda's6.4
  155. Casa 736.4
  156. Hey Lucy6.4
  157. Sal's Pasta & Chops6.4
  158. Zia's Place6.4
  159. Ammucca Sicilian Street Food6.4
  160. Trecce6.4
  161. La Veranda Osteria6.4
  162. Ficoa6.4
  163. La Famiglia on the Danforth6.4
  164. DaNico6.4
  165. Pizzeria Libretto6.3
  166. Alobar6.3
  167. Uncle Tony's6.3
  168. Mercatto6.3
  169. Little Anthony's6.3
  170. Primadonna Restaurant & Rooftop6.3
  171. Scaccia6.2
  172. Tony & Nick's Place6.2
  173. Dal Moro's Fresh Pasta To Go6.2
  174. Via Allegro Ristorante6.2
  175. Good Son6.2
  176. Dough Box6.1
  177. Dannys6.1
  178. Alfie's Sandwiches & Market6.1
  179. La Fenice6.1
  180. Papamio's6.1
  181. Paisano's6.1
  182. Juniors Pizzeria6.1
  183. Occhiolino6.1
  184. Lume Kitchen and Lounge6.0
  185. Sicilian Sidewalk Café6.0
  186. Victory Cafe5.9
  187. Actinolite Restaurant5.9
  188. La Rose Specialty Foods & Fine Italian Bakery5.9
  189. Bar Roma Toronto5.9
  190. Pizzeria Moretti5.8
  191. Sip Wine Bar5.8
  192. The Parlour5.7
  193. Edna + Vita5.7
  194. The Hungry Italian (Dragon/Mickey's Pizza)5.7
  195. Piano Piano5.5
  196. La Vecchia5.4
  197. Bitondo's Pizzeria5.4
  198. Dear Darling5.4
  199. N.L. Ginzburg5.4
  200. Dimmi Bar & Trattoria5.4
  201. Sugo5.3
  202. Sotto Sotto5.2
  203. Amano Italian Kitchen5.2
  204. La Palma5.1
  205. Vie Strada Food & Drink (Clandestino)5.1
  206. Vero Italian Sandwich Co.5.0
  207. Commisso Bros. & Racco Italian Bakery5.0
  208. Vagabondo Restobar4.9
  209. Vivo Pizza + Pasta4.8
  210. Positano Restaurant4.7
  211. Grazie Ristorante4.7
  212. Freebird Market4.7
  213. Scaddabush4.6
  214. Pizza Rustica Restaurant & Bar4.6
  215. Café Diplomatico4.5
  216. Nonna Lia4.2
  217. Coppi Ristorante4.1
  218. Terroni3.9
  219. Oretta3.5
  220. Proper3.4
  221. Don Alfonso 18903.3
  222. Porzia's3.2
  223. Public Gardens3.2
  224. Cafe Renée3.1
  225. Mama Martino's2.2
  226. Cibo1.4
  227. Don Alfonso 18901.0