Proper

What Reddit says

Roncesvalles restaurant with sharply mixed reviews. Some praise the tartare and pasta, while others found dishes salty or undercooked and the food mediocre. Slow, poor service is a common complaint.

Paraphrased from the comments below.

What to order

• 6.9
  Pasta3 Redditors
  Worth trying
• 6.9
  Tartare#7 for tartare in Toronto
  Worth trying

In their words

Short excerpts, each linked to the full comment on Reddit.

• “food was very good. I think the tartar is some of the best in the city”

• “the chicken parm was so salty it was barely edible and the meatballs were undercooked”

• “I went recently and was so disappointed”

• “Went here recently and the pasta was very good, everything else was mediocre.”

• “The food was good, but it was pretty loud. I'd probably go back with a group of 4.”

• “I went about a month ago, it was noooot good”

• “Food was mid at best and service was AWFUL”

• “Got cancelled on 10 minutes before our reservation time due to rain”

• “Still had a good meal but that was odd, especially considering we dropped $300.”

• “Food is yum but service is soooooo slow.”

• “That's a great serving of beef tartare!”

• “I tried Proper and didn't have a good experience tbh”