#3,333 in Toronto. 111 Redditors across 165 mentions, Jan 2024 to Oct 2026.
What Reddit says
Baldwin Street sandwich shop known for its Italian sandwich and cheesesteak. Many Redditors say it lives up to the hype, while others find it overrated and pricey at around $20 per sandwich.
Paraphrased from the comments below.
What to order
- 8.8Italian Sandwiches (veal, porchetta)#8 for Italian sandwiches (veal, porchetta) in TorontoWorth trying
- 6.2Sandwiches70 RedditorsWorth trying
- Bread3 Redditors
- Burgers1 Redditor
In their words
Short excerpts, each linked to the full comment on Reddit.
“a heads up is always nice when a resteraunt is straight up scamming. At $20 per sammich that's quite the investment.”
Not a fanr/FoodToronto, Jul 2026Read on Reddit (opens in a new tab) “It's a bit overrated. The one time I went, the sandwhich had very little flavor”
Not a fanr/FoodToronto, Jul 2026Read on Reddit (opens in a new tab) “all still great, not a knock against them.”
Liked itr/askTO, Aug 2026Read on Reddit (opens in a new tab) “I ended up trying the Mona Lisa and the Truffle Affair, and both sandwiches were amazing.”
Liked itr/FoodToronto, Jul 2026Read on Reddit (opens in a new tab) “Overall, I loved them both but i’m not sure if I’ll want to pay +$50 for these again.”
Liked itr/FoodToronto, Jul 2026Read on Reddit (opens in a new tab) “if you like a great cheesesteak Alfie’s isn’t cheap but if filling and tasty”
Liked itr/FoodToronto, Nov 2025Read on Reddit (opens in a new tab) “Alfie sandwich I heard makes a really good Italian Sandwich”
Liked it (secondhand)r/FoodToronto, Jul 2026Read on Reddit (opens in a new tab) “very expensive for what I found to be a very mediocre sandwich”
Not a fanr/FoodToronto, Jul 2026Read on Reddit (opens in a new tab) “worth the hype in my opinion”
Liked itr/FoodToronto, Jul 2025Read on Reddit (opens in a new tab) “I like the Sofia and their Chicken and Bacon Caesar. The price is a bit high, but portions are good, as is quality.”
Liked itr/FoodToronto, Jul 2026Read on Reddit (opens in a new tab) “The amount of prosciutto on that sandwich is criminal...the only good thing is the freshly baked bread.”
Not a fanr/FoodToronto, Jul 2025Read on Reddit (opens in a new tab) “here's a few I enjoyed and like to go back”
Liked itr/FoodToronto, Jun 2026Read on Reddit (opens in a new tab)
More in Chinatown
- 9.0
48 Redditors
- 9.0
77 Redditors
- 8.7
43 Redditors
- 8.6
Crumbs Gourmet PattiesTemporarily closed
50 Redditors