Papa Mio's

What Reddit says

Known for subs, especially the meatball and eggplant, and thick chocolate chip cookies that several call among the city's best. One Redditor reported stomach trouble after eating there, but most feedback is very positive.

Paraphrased from the comments below.

What to order

• 9.0
  Cookies#4 for cookies in Toronto
  Top pick
• 8.8
  Italian Sandwiches (veal#6 for Italian sandwiches (veal in Toronto
  Worth trying
• Sandwiches2 Redditors
• Fried Chicken Sandwiches1 Redditor

In their words

Short excerpts, each linked to the full comment on Reddit.

• “their baked goods rockkkk…especially the chocolate chip cookies, it’s one of the best in the city!”

• “the Eggplant sandwich at Papamios on Dupont is 100% the best in the city”

• “the sub is fantastic and you leave feeling wholesome for some reason”

• “really thick, chunky chocolate chip cookies; I particularly like the triple chocolate one”

• “The guy who runs Papamios is right up his alley too.”

• “The guy who runs Papamios is right up his alley too.”

• “My wife and I split the magnifico hot chicken sandwich and the eggplant parm. Absolutely phenomenal”

• “Love papamios! The meat ball sub is legit. Same with the cookies”

• “both times have absolutely dumped gut immediately afterwards”