Cataldi Fresh Market

What to order

• Cookies1 Redditor
• Pizza1 Redditor

In their words

Short excerpts, each linked to the full comment on Reddit.

• “I hit up Cataldi foods in north York for the $2.50 bomba”

• “San Remo, Cataldi, Rustic Bakery”

• “Cataldi has killer ones”

• “I've seen it in Italian grocers such as Lady York, Cataldi, Rustic Bakery”

• “All three are available at Cataldi near Yorkdale.”

• “Tre Mari or Cataldi”

• “Cataldi”