Don Alfonso 1890

What Reddit says

Upscale Italian fine dining spot, often listed among Toronto's Michelin-level restaurants. The tasting menu gets praise, while one Redditor found it too expensive and not memorable.

Paraphrased from the comments below.

What to order

• Tasting Menus5 Redditors
• Pasta3 Redditors

In their words

Short excerpts, each linked to the full comment on Reddit.

• “There's also Black + Blue at Casa Loma, Don Alfonso 1890, Kiin, and Grey Gardens could be worthy choices too”

• “Don Alfonso is a bit more artful.”

• “|Don Alfonso 1890|225|Available|No|”

• “Worst $300 I've spent in a fine dining restaurant.”

• “don alfonso is almost universally panned on here (by me as well, tasting menu was *not* good)”

• “I have and I would strongly recommend against it. For the price point the quality is just not good at all.”

• “If you want really fine dining then Don Alfonso 1890 is on the 38th floor of the Westin Harbourfront”

• “don alfonso is the fancy michelin-starred spot around there if you really want to splurge”

• “It was not. One of Toronto's more disappointing Michelin restaurants”

• “Avoid Don Alfonso.”

• “seems like few people here have had good experiences there (me included)”

• “Don Alfonso is another option, but probably a fair bit more expensive than CN Tower (but considerably better”