Mystic Muffin

What Reddit says

Small cafe near Jarvis and Adelaide known for its apple cake and loaves such as banana blueberry chocolate chip. Redditors call it cheap and cheerful, and often mention the friendly owner and solid food.

Paraphrased from the comments below.

What to order

• 9.7
  Cake#2 for cake in Toronto
  Top pick
• Bagels4 Redditors
• Sandwiches4 Redditors
• Bread3 Redditors
• Falafel2 Redditors
• Jamaican Patties2 Redditors
• Breakfast Sandwich1 Redditor
• Coffee1 Redditor

In their words

Short excerpts, each linked to the full comment on Reddit.

• “Go get your apple cake, banana loaf, and sandwiches, guys.”

• “33 year old mom and pop restaurant and he would sit down and listen to Elias’ stories and jokes for hours.”

• “Everything about it was perfect.”

• “Mystic Muffin's Apple cake is dangerous in the best way and Elias is such a gem”

• “Take it home, put it back in the oven to heat it up and slap some vanilla ice cream on that. My GOODNESS”

• “Love mystic muffin!!! The owner is such a nice dude.”

• “I’m so happy to see this place still going”

• “Try the apple cake! He'll try to upsell you on it lol but it's genuinely good”

• “My husband sometimes buys an apple cake for treat Thursdays at his work, and brings a slice home for me. It's so good!”

• “Take an apple cake back to your office. You want to be a popular guy? Get the apple cake.”

• “Mystic Muffin is a 10 minute walk for a very good apple cake”

• “I love the owner Elias and his wife. Amazing people and delicious food.”