Donatello

What Reddit says

A long-standing Italian restaurant near Yonge and Dundas, praised for good food, service and atmosphere. Regulars have ordered the same pasta dish for decades. One visitor liked the seafood but was disappointed by the steak and dessert.

Paraphrased from the comments below.

What to order

• Pasta2 Redditors
• Desserts1 Redditor
• Seafood1 Redditor
• Steak1 Redditor

In their words

Short excerpts, each linked to the full comment on Reddit.

• “I have been coming here since I was born and I have ordered the same dish (spaghetti 2000) for 30+ years”

• “I had a nice time at Donatello on Elm Street (near Eaton Centre). Good food, nice place, good service.”

• “Donatello’s near Yonge and Dundas is very good - place, service, food - all very good.”

• “our table was very satisfied with the seafood dishes and very unsatisfied with the steak and dessert”

• “A few places that might work downtown: • Edna + Vita • Donatello Restaurant • Mercatto • Little Anthony’s”

• “my top 3 are Donatellos Gio Ranas aka "The Nose" 7 Numbers in that order”

• “I had a lovely meal there - I can recommend it enough.”

• “We do love Donatellos”

• “Great ambiance, food and staff.”

• “Donatello on Elm street has an upstairs. We reserved a party of 12 last year and they put us up there.”

• “Donatello Restaurant is Italian”