Sweetie Pie

What Reddit says

Mostly negative feedback about the location at The Well. Redditors describe frozen, freezer-burnt pies, ice cream that isn't kept cold enough, and mediocre quality across locations. A few mention it only as a convenient stop.

Paraphrased from the comments below.

What to order

• 9.4
  Butter Tarts#5 for butter tarts in Toronto
  Top pick
• 1.0
  Pie#5 for pie in Toronto
  Top pick
• Cookies3 Redditors
• Cake1 Redditor
• Desserts1 Redditor
• Ice Cream & Gelato1 Redditor
• Pastries1 Redditor
• Vegan Food1 Redditor

In their words

Short excerpts, each linked to the full comment on Reddit.

• “I was shamed for buying the large size ice cream here. The ice cream was also not kept cold enough.”

• “they just weren’t very good. Tried a few times and their products didn’t present well and more importantly didn’t taste good”

• “Sweetie Pie hadn't been great at any of their locations”

• “the ice cream bunker was definitely not being kept cool enough.”

• “everything is frozen and pies are freezer burnt”

• “I went over and bought one and it was cold and hard, like they had been sitting in the back all day.”

• “I’m going to Distillery and going to Soma/Sweetie Pie or to Cluny for a pastry.”

• “the pie is not good”

• “I got it home, cut a slice and water came flowing out and it was all separated. It wasn’t edible.”

• “Tried it once it really wasn’t very good.”

• “all they are is only slightly above average offerings in terms of quality, below average in quantity, and completely out of touch pricing”

• “The fillings are like those shitty canned, gloppy kind.”