The Maids' Cottage

What Reddit says

Known mainly for butter tarts, which many Redditors call the best in Ontario. One commenter disagreed and didn't enjoy the ones they tried. Some note the tarts are also sold at other shops, but visiting the Newmarket location is praised.

Paraphrased from the comments below.

What to order

• 8.5
  Butter Tarts#11 for butter tarts in Toronto
  Worth trying

In their words

Short excerpts, each linked to the full comment on Reddit.

• “IMO, the GOAT-tier Ontario butter tart is from The Maid's Cottage in Newmarket.”

• “The Maid's Cottage seems to be a popular choice, but I didn't like the ones I tried.”

• “You can try Maid's Cottage at Rachel's near Yonge and Davisville.”

• “The best butter tarts are found at the Maid’s Cottage in Newmarket.”

• “Fresh Harvest on Eglinton sells Maid’s Cottage butter tarts. They are quite good.”

• “though going to the actual resto is great”

• “Now, for the best one, come up to the maid’s cottage in Newmarket”

• “Maid’s Cottage.”

• “Maid’s cottage in Newmarket”

• “Epicure Shop, AM Bagel, Hunter Coffee : sourced from Maids Cottage”

• “There's the Sweet Oven (many people love this but they may not have a location in Toronto anymore) and Maids Cottage.”

• “1st Place Professional Wild Style Winner: The Maid's Cottage's Black Forest Mocha”