Circles & Squares Bakery

What Reddit says

Best known for butter tarts, including a coconut cream pie version, plus brownies. Some Redditors call the butter tarts the best in the city, and the salads and sandwiches also get positive mentions.

Paraphrased from the comments below.

What to order

• 8.8
  Butter Tarts#8 for butter tarts in Toronto
  Worth trying
• 8.1
  Croissants14 Redditors
  Worth trying
• 7.7
  Bread#23 for bread in Toronto
  Worth trying
• 7.5
  Cake12 Redditors
  Worth trying
• 7.5
  Coffee11 Redditors
  Worth trying
• 7.2
  Cinnamon & Cardamom Buns#11 for cinnamon & cardamom buns in Toronto
  Worth trying
• 6.8
  Pastries13 Redditors
  Worth trying
• Cookies3 Redditors

In their words

Short excerpts, each linked to the full comment on Reddit.

• “People really liked the texture of the cake which I completely agree with.”

• “it’s a really well balanced butter tart”

• “Another top tier, very delicious, decent amount of icing”

• “Circles and Squares has killer cinnamon rolls on weekends.”

• “circles and squares across the street also has amazing butter tarts and other pastries”

• “Their banana pudding was pretty solid overall”

• “Circle & Squares Bakery is nearby in East York. And they’re good!”

• “Holy yum! This everything bagel croissant with herb cream cheese was delicious and a nice treat”

• “It's rated as one of the best and most popular bakeries in Toronto with 2 locations (and lives up to the hype imo)”

• “Circles and Squares have a new location at King West”

• “Circle and Square’s butter tarts are good and if you want traditional, the raisin and the plain are both good.”

• “Circles & Squares if you want some variety.”