Greg's Ice Cream

What Reddit says

Remembered fondly for its roasted marshmallow ice cream, which several people call the best version they've had. Many talk about it nostalgically, as a favourite from years ago.

Paraphrased from the comments below.

What to order

• 9.6
  Ice Cream & Gelato#1 for ice cream & gelato in Toronto
  Top pick

In their words

Short excerpts, each linked to the full comment on Reddit.

• “Honest to god it was better than this!!! I still dream of it.”

• “Greg’s roasted marshmallow was INCREDIBLE.”

• “Greg’s was toasted marshmallow flavour throughout, and DEEPLY toasted (but never burnt tasting).”

• “a Roasted Marshmallow that I would eat until I barfed it was that good”

• “Shout out to Greg's where I first had it also.”

• “take them to a really good North American ice cream spot lol Greg’s”

• “My Favourite was the first place I ever had this flavour.”

• “I miss Greg's roasted marshmallow ice cream.”

• “Greg's was the first place I saw that made this flavour”

• “Was a massive fan of Greg's back in the day.”

• “I thought the Greg's Ice Cream (RIP) was better.”

• “wood paneling and neon decor were such a vibe”