One Night Only Pizza

What Reddit says

A small Pape Avenue pizza shop often named among the best pizza in Toronto, especially New York style. Redditors also mention solid wings, and some prefer it to Badiali.

Paraphrased from the comments below.

What to order

• 9.1
  Pizza#6 for pizza in Toronto
  Worth trying
• 7.8
  Pizza by the Slice#16 for pizza by the slice in Toronto
  Worth trying
• Wings1 Redditor

In their words

Short excerpts, each linked to the full comment on Reddit.

• “flavours on point, slightly doughy for my liking but def would return”

• “the best pizza I've had in Toronto is One Night Only (ONO) on Pape.”

• “One Night Only in the east end is a new favourite for me”

• “Definitely check out our NY pizza spots as they rival some of the best in North America outside NY”

• “you might aswell try One Night Only Pizza they’re also East end(slices Wednesday - Saturday)”

• “Lorenzo's Pizza up pape is on par with ONO and Toronto's other contenders”

• “You’re not a real east ender if you’re not including One Night Only and even Descendants”

• “Nice Slice Mac’s Grams Fresca Fourth Man in the Fire One Night Only Gracie’s”

• “One night only pizza”

• “One night only. No questions asked.”

• “One night only and Lorenzo’s in the east end definitely worth a try”

• “Grabbing a pickup pizza at One Night Only for a night in is also great.”