Prince Street Pizza

What Reddit says

Seen as a close approximation of New York style pizza, with the meat lovers square getting some praise. Opinions are split: several rank it low or call it overrated, citing the long lineups at The Well.

Paraphrased from the comments below.

What to order

• 7.5
  Pizza by the Slice#19 for pizza by the slice in Toronto
  Worth trying
• 4.0
  Pizza22 Redditors
  Worth trying
• Detroit & Square Pizza2 Redditors
• Steak1 Redditor
• Sushi1 Redditor

In their words

Short excerpts, each linked to the full comment on Reddit.

• “contentious pick because they're inconsistent, but imo, weekday crew is way better than weekend crew”

• “Prince St Pizza (the Well): 5/10”

• “the Naughty Pie made right from Prince Street is among the best the city has to offer”

• “it's not the best pizza in Toronto but it's pretty much the closest to emulating the average NY style pizza”

• “Grams, Decendants, Danny's & Prince Street are above those IMO”

• “the service at Prince Street is easily the worst part about Prince Street.”

• “I partially hate ordering from them because it is always 30-60 minutes later than they say it will be.”

• “prince street is brutally bad”

• “IMO, prince is at the bottom of the pizza list.”

• “waited in line and tried the new Prince Street Pizza that opened”

• “I had their meat lovers square last week and I'll happily disagree.”

• “prince street hits the spot for me when I have munchies”