Skip to content
UpvoteEats, Toronto

The best pizza in Islington, Toronto

Ranked by Reddit

3 places in Islington ranked for pizza, from what 23 Redditors said about it. Scores are for the pizza specifically, not the restaurant overall.

Last updated . How the ranking works

  1. 7.6#1

    1. Donatelli's PizzeriaWorth trying

    Pizza in Islington

    4 Redditors on the pizza

    “it is a pretty tasty and I would be lying if said I don't perk up a bit because of it”

    Liked itr/FoodToronto, May 2025Read on Reddit (opens in a new tab)
  2. 7.3#2

    2. Milano's PizzaWorth trying

    Pizza, Italian in Islington

    16 Redditors on the pizza

    “Out in Etobicoke, I go with Milano’s”

    Liked itr/askTO, Oct 2026Read on Reddit (opens in a new tab)
  3. 5.7#3

    3. Pizza DepotWorth tryingTemporarily closed

    Pizza, Indian in Islington

    3 Redditors on the pizza

    “Paneer pizza from pizza depot slaps”

    Liked itr/askTO, Mar 2026Read on Reddit (opens in a new tab)