Carousel Bakery

What Reddit says

St. Lawrence Market stall famous for its peameal bacon sandwich, which many call the definitive Toronto version. It is cash only. Baked goods like butter tarts get a more lukewarm reception.

Paraphrased from the comments below.

What to order

• 8.2
  Breakfast Sandwich#11 for breakfast sandwich in Toronto
  Worth trying
• 6.1
  Peameal Bacon Sandwich#4 for peameal bacon sandwich in Toronto
  Top pick
• Apple Fritters2 Redditors
• Butter Tarts2 Redditors
• Portuguese Tarts2 Redditors
• Sandwiches2 Redditors
• Egg Tarts1 Redditor

In their words

Short excerpts, each linked to the full comment on Reddit.

• “Got this from the OG Carousel Bakery at St. Lawrence Market and had the absolute pleasure of chatting with one of the co-owners, Robert”

• “Carousel Bakery in St Lawrence Market offers the best version of one of the most qunintessentially Toronto foods: the peameal bacon sandwich.”

• “I’ve been eating these sandwiches my whole life.”

• “Tried the peameal bacon sandwich from Carousel Bakery”

• “peameal bacon sandwiches from Carousel bakery which are more of a unique find”

• “My vote would be for the Apple fritter at Carousel Bakery in St.Lawrence Market”

• “You know it's good when they have piles ready to go and every single one of them is fresh off the griddle hot.”

• “I prefer the breakfast over the straight peameal, with hot sauce, sometimes mustard too.”

• “get a pemeal bacon (ie. Canadian bacon) sandwhich at the Carousel bakery.”

• “Carousel has a popular local version (make sure to get mustard)”

• “Head to the Carousel Bakery at the St. Lawerence Market for a peameal bacon on a bun.”

• “a peameal bacon sandwich with egg and cheese (cash only) from Carousel Bakery in main hall”