Gerrard St. Bakery

What Reddit says

A Gerrard East bakery famous for butter tarts, often called the best in the city. Lemon tarts and the butter tart cake or pie also get praise.

Paraphrased from the comments below.

What to order

• 7.9
  Butter Tarts#13 for butter tarts in Toronto
  Worth trying
• Cake3 Redditors
• Desserts1 Redditor
• Pie1 Redditor

In their words

Short excerpts, each linked to the full comment on Reddit.

• “Prob my fav butter tart along w Gerrard St Bakery.”

• “They even make a cake with their butter tarts, perfect for taking to holiday get togethers.”

• “Gerrard st Bakery - can’t go wrong with anything here”

• “The best butter tart around. Their lemon tarts are amazing too”

• “the other options mentioned in this thread (namely: Circles and Squares and Gerrard St Bakery)”

• “I quite liked the tartness of the key lime pie from Gerrard St Bakery”

• “The butter tart cake is delicious!”

• “Gerrard St Bakery”

• “The best butter tart I’ve found in Toronto.”

• “I am not a fan. Just tastes like surgery lard.”

• “I'm partial to the Butter Tart Pie from Gerrard St Bakery”

• “I like Gerrard St Bakery for various squares.”