Lucali

What Reddit says

Brooklyn, New York pizzeria, not a GTA business. Redditors rank it among the best pizza in NYC, with the calzone singled out. One says the newer slice shop was weaker at opening.

Paraphrased from the comments below.

What to order

• Pizza2 Redditors
• Calzones1 Redditor

In their words

Short excerpts, each linked to the full comment on Reddit.

• “Lucali and L'industrie are good selections from this list for NY, having lived by both and gone many times”

• “Lucali I heard the new slice shop is not good (when it first opened anyway). I've only been to the original place.”

• “Best pizza in NYC is still Lucali and it’s not even close.”

• “Try Lucalis and Di Fara next”

• “Personally Lucalis personally is better than them all.”

• “Try the Lucali calzone (not slice shop).”

• “Di Fara and Industrie are on the same level I rate Lucalis below both of them”

• “Lucali is still one of the best”

• “Pizza Studio Tamaki in Tokyo, and Lucali in Brooklyn.”

• “Also sometimes you can get marinara to dip, like at Lucali, though that’s better suited to the calzone.”

• “Yet to try Lucali because it’s so out of the way”