Prairie Girl Bakery

What Reddit says

Cupcake bakery, later rebranded as Sticky, remembered mainly for its red velvet cupcakes. Redditors speak of it fondly and say they miss it, treating it as closed.

Paraphrased from the comments below.

What to order

• 9.2
  Cake#18 for cake in Toronto
  Worth trying
• 7.3
  Cupcakes#5 for cupcakes in Toronto
  Top pick

In their words

Short excerpts, each linked to the full comment on Reddit.

• “I bought that cookbook yesterday at the shop so I don’t have to say good bye forever to the BEST icing.”

• “I love that strawberry icing & miss it dearly.”

• “That strawberry frosting from prairie girl was the best cupcake frosting I’ve ever ever had!!!”

• “Prairie Girl was the predecessor business to Sticky and the cupcakes were the same.”

• “I miss Prairie Girl Bakery’s red velvet cupcakes…”

• “They were so good.”

• “I still grieve the loss of prairie girl bakery!”

• “Prairie Girl cupcakes 😭 I still haven't recovered.”

• “I miss Prairie Girl so much”

• “From Prairie Girl Bakery, they closed in 2021 due to the pandemic”

• “Prairie Girl was OVERRATED as fuck and way too sugary for a cupcake”

• “nothing will match a prairie girl / sticky cupcake.”